I calculated the consensus a bit differently this time. Instead of using raw site rankings I isolated the position and reranked each list P1-P150 depending on how many pitchers were included. This gives us a clearer comparison and eliminates some of the variance due to ranking styles and brands. Prospect lists incorporated include Fangraphs, Fantrax, MLB.com, Prospects1500, Prospects Live, and Prospects Worldwide. Players have to appear on multiple lists to be considered for these rankings.

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
1	MacKenzie Gore	SD	–	21	–	AA	–	L	–	1	–	2
2	Nate Pearson	TOR		24		MLB		R		2		8
3	Sixto Sanchez	MIA		22		MLB		R		1		7
4	Casey Mize	DET		23		MLB		R		2		8
5	Ian Anderson	ATL		22		MLB		R		3		15
6	Matt Manning	DET		22		AA		R		3		20
7	Luis Patino	SD		21		MLB		R		3		14
8	Grayson Rodriguez	BAL		21		A		R		5		14
9	Forrest Whitley	HOU		23		AAA		R		5		21
10	Michael Kopech	CHW		24		MLB		R		5		23

No huge surprises here but there rarely are at the top. Six of the top ten pitchers have already made their MLB debut. Manning was ranked everywhere from 3rd (Fantrax) to 20th (Prospects Live). Whitley ranged from 5th to 21st (Prospects Live). Kopech would have been higher if not for being 23rd on Prospects Worldwide’s list (and for good reason). I’m a Grayson Rodriguez fan but wasn’t expecting him to crack the top ten.

Rank	Name		Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
11	Spencer Howard	–	PHI	–	24	–	MLB	–	R	–	7	–	17
12	Asa Lacy		KC		21		FYPD		L		10		16
13	Logan Gilbert		SEA		23		AA		R		6		16
14	Max Meyer		MIA		21		FYPD		R		7		27
15	Emerson Hancock		SEA		21		FYPD		R		8		25
16	Tarik Skubal		DET		24		MLB		L		12		27
17	Nick Lodolo		CIN		22		A		L		18		30
18	Edward Cabrera		MIA		22		AA		R		10		29
19	Josiah Gray		LAD		22		AA		R		14		39
20	DL Hall		BAL		22		A+		L		15		29

–

Rank	Name			Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
21	George Kirby	–		SEA	–	22	–	A-	–	R	–	6	–	40
22	Brendan McKay			TB		25		MLB		L		4		57
23	Hunter Greene			CIN		21		A		R		19		31
24	Clarke Schmidt			NYY		24		MLB		R		16		39
25	Daniel Lynch			KC		24		A+		L		22		29
26	Simeon Woods-Richardson			TOR		20		A+		R		21		34
27	Matthew Liberatore			STL		21		A		L		17		45
28	Deivi Garcia			NYY		21		MLB		R		12		48
29	Brailyn Marquez			CHC		21		MLB		L		19		37
30	Shane Baz			TB		21		A		R		21		41

Brendan McKay is inexplicably ranked as the fourth pitcher and 12th overall on MLB.com’s list. He’s much lower everywhere else. Prospects Worldwide lists him as their #57 pitching prospect. Speaking of PWW they’re also by far the highest on George Kirby, ranking him as their sixth pitcher. Kirby was not listed among Fangraphs’ top 100 prospects. They also rank Clarke Schmidt ten spots behind any of the other sites at 39. Liberatore is in the top 20 on three lists but 45th on Prospects Live’s. Deivi Garcia is Fangraphs’ 12th ranked pitcher but Fantrax lists him at 48. He’s always been divisive due to his height. Fantrax is also the only list to include Brailyn Marquez in their top 20. Baz expectedly had a large variance in rankings due to differing opinions concerning his future role.

Rank	Name		Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
31	A.J. Puk	–	OAK	–	25	–	MLB	–	L	–	13	–	60
32	Jordan Balazovic		MIN		22		A+		R		22		38
33	Mick Abel		PHI		19		FYPD		R		20		40
34	Garrett Crochet		CWS		21		FYPD		L		25		40
35	Daniel Espino		CLE		19		A-		R		19		40
36	Triston McKenzie		CLE		23		MLB		R		19		42
37	Ethan Hankins		CLE		20		A		R		30		46
38	Jackson Kowar		KC		24		AA		R		32		54
39	Tahnaj Thomas		PIT		21		RK		R		26		56
40	Nick Bitsko		TB		18		FYPD		R		33		50

Puk still made two top-15 appearances. PWW had the lowest ranking with 60th. Balazovic checked in at 22nd on The Board at Fangraphs. Fantrax lists Mick Abel as their 20th best pitching prospect, considerably higher than the other outlets. Neither Abel or Crochet cracked Fangraphs’ top 100 overall prospect list. Espino got a big boost fom PWW, who ranked him 19th. Triston McKenzie cracked Prospects Live’s top 20. Jackson Kowar and Tahnaj Thomas were torpedoed by Fantrax listing them as the 54th and 56th pitching prospects. Fangraphs listed Tahnaj as their 26th pitcher.

Rank	Name		Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
41	Shane McClanahan	–	TB	–	23	–	AA	–	L	–	37	–	46
42	Reid Detmers		LAA		21		FYPD		L		26		57
43	Dane Dunning		TEX		26		MLB		R		36		50
44	Jackson Rutledge		WAS		21		A		R		25		62
45	Cade Cavalli		WAS		22		FYPD		R		43		61
46	Alek Manoah		TOR		22		A-		R		40		55
47	Jhoan Duran		MIN		22		AA		R		18		65
48	Bryce Jarvis		ARI		23		FYPD		R		45		64
49	Matthew Allan		NYM		19		A-		R		39		78
50	Tanner Houck		BOS		23		MLB		R		40		81

MLB.com is by far the highest on Detmers with a ranking of 26. Jackson Rutledge was ranked everywhere from 25th (PWW) to 62nd (Prospects1500). Cade Cavalli is between 40-44 on every list that went that deep except P1500, which listed him 61st. They’re also significantly lower on Bryce Jarvis (64) than the other lists used. Fangraphs ranked Jhoan Duran 20+ spots higher than any outlet at 18 (and I love it). Prospects Live nuked Matt Allan’s consensus ranking by slotting him at 78 (24 spots lower than anyone else). Fantrax lists Houck as their #82 pitching prospect, 36 spots behind the next lowest ranking.

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
51	Cole Wilcox	SD	–	21	–	FYPD	–	R	–	45	–	64
52	Slade Cecconi	ARI		21		FYPD		R		31		70
53	Bobby Miller	LAD		21		FYPD		R		47		74
54	Ryan Weathers	SD		21		MLB		L		54		66
55	Quinn Priester	PIT		20		A-		R		51		75
56	Jay Groome	BOS		22		A-		L		49		78
57	Blake Walston	ARI		19		A-		L		41		102
58	Joey Cantillo	SD		19		RK		L		52		76
59	Daulton Jefferies	OAK		24		AAA		R		47		82
60	Braxton Garrett	MIA		23		MLB		L		52		80

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
61	Joe Ryan	TB	–	24	–	AA	–	R	–	37	–	91
62	Bryan Mata	BOS		21		AA		R		56		80
63	Brent Honeywell	TB		24		AAA		R		40		94
64	Luis Medina	NYY		20		AA		R		58		81
65	Jared Kelley	CWS		19		FYPD		R		33		107
66	Adam Kloffenstein	TOR		20		A-		R		60		79
67	Brennan Malone	PIT		20		A-		R		53		91
68	Seth Corry	SF		22		A		L		35		82
69	Luis Gil	NYY		22		A+		R		49		99
70	Ethan Small	MIL		23		A		L		68		82

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
71	Tanner Burns	CLE	–	21	–	FYPD	–	R	–	49	–	99
72	Luis Frias	ARI		22		A		R		57		99
73	Clayton Beeter	LAD		22		FYPD		R		57		87
74	Jared Shuster	ATL		22		FYPD		L		61		97
75	Zack Thompson	STL		23		A+		L		71		88
76	Antoine Kelly	MIL		21		A		L		68		92
77	Jairo Solis	HOU		20		A		R		78		85
78	Corbin Martin	ARI		23		AAA		R		33		95
79	Alexander Vizcaino	NYY		22		AA		R		84		85
80	Jared Jones	PIT		19		FYPD		R		58		100

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
81	Noah Song	BOS	–	22	–	School	–	R	–	52	–	110
82	Dax Fulton	MIA		19		FYPD		L		59		132
83	Robert Dominguez	NYM		19		RK		R		82		90
84	JT Ginn	NYM		21		FYPD		R		58		114
85	Seth Johnson	TB		22		RK		R		83		96
86	Kyle Muller	ATL		22		AA		L		67		99
87	Ricky Vanasco	TEX		22		A		R		75		99
88	Masyn Winn	STL		18		FYPD		R		72		119
89	Thad Ward	BOS		22		A+		R		92		93
90	Cole Winn	TEX		21		A		R		51		117

Rank	Name	Org		Age		Level		T		High		Low
91	JJ Goss	TB	–	19	–	RK	–	R	–	88	–	98
92	Jack Kochanowicz	LAA		19		FYPD		R		71		105
93	Lenny Torres	CLE		20		RK		R		56		138
94	Alex Santos	HOU		18		FYPD		R		66		130
95	Ryan Rolison	COL		22		AA		L		35		103
96	Kendall Williams	LAD		20		RK		R		70		129
97	Kyle Harrison	SF		19		FYPD		L		82		118
98	Chris Rodriguez	LAA		22		A+		R		59		142
99	CJ Van Eyk	TOR		21		FYPD		R		73		113
100	J.B. Bukauskas	ARI		23		AA		R		62		124
101	Francisco Morales	PHI		20		A		R		90		121
102	Mason Denaburg	WAS		20		RK		R		68		128
103	Yerry Rodriguez	TEX		23		A		R		32		155
104	Brusdar Graterol	MIN		21		MLB		R		32		157
105	Josh Wolf	NYM		20		RK		R		79		133
106	Luis Garcia	HOU		23		AA		R		86		147